I was going to write down all of the museum things that need donating for my own reference, I figured I might as well make that information easy for others to see as well?
Supernatural Room
Cosmic Globe
Witch’s Hat
Googly Soup (2 star)
Mana Extractor
Mystic Cauldron
Vampire Collection:
Bloody Mana Mary (2 star)
Bat Skull
Blood Chalice
Malakar’s Coffin
Red Wine (2 star)
Gothic Mirror
Black Azalea
Seer Collection:
Coil of Fate
Seer Board
Third Eye Hand
Decorative Glass Pane
Moon Crystal
White Rose
Blue Moonlight Flower
Werewolf Collection:
Moonreaver
The Timber Beast
Wolf’s Prey
Mana Moon Cupcake (2 star)
Farmer’s Stew (2 star)
Fur Chair
Wolfsbane Powder
Mermaid Collection:
Altar Ornament
Poseidon’s Trident
Seahorse Sculpture
Shell Lantern
Fishy Milkshake (2 star)
Dried Seaweed
Aquatic Cabinet
Beach Lantern
Deity Room
Chakra Tuner
Death’s Tomb
Llemi’s Bow
Sun God’s Halo
Farming Room (All 2 star)
Angry Mandrake
Blood Orange
Lemon
Muse Nut
Weeping Wicca
Amanita
Black Sun Currant
Blackberry
Blood Grape
Blood Tomato
Blueberry
Carrot
Clawy Vera
Common Mushroom
Cranberry
Cruelcumber
Dark Strawberry
Drikker
Eggplant
Frosteria
Glowglammer
Gobbler
Happy Mandrake
Hold-Me-Close
Lava Pepper
Melon
Moonfruit
Onion
Pumpkin
Radish
Raspberry
Red Corn
Skunktail
Strawberry
Sugarbone
Sunburst
Sweet Wicca
Unmilled Rice
Void Radish
Volacio
White Grape
Wild Potato
Wily Wheat
Yellow Glowglammer
Cocoa Bean
Coffee Bean
Glow Ginger
Googly Garlic
Henbane
Purple Lavender
Sage
Suffrain
Wolfsbane
Aquarium
Brickle
Daybreaker
Fortipod
Furybud
Glammer
Glibby
Gloy Gloy
Gnasher
Goldy
Goliath
Leftsee
Moonflutter
Mouthout
Orbis
Skullfin
Snuffy
Splotch
Twilight
Violet
Whisper
Critter Room
Aura
Autumn Wing
Batterfly
Begoniflap
Beige Breezer
Blue Gulf
Blue Swallow
Blueleaf
Bluey
Blushbug
Buzzer
Citrineflutter
Deviled Sunny
Diamontra
Dreamshell
Fader
Firefly
Flamboyance
Frost Flutter
Frostleaf
Glorph
Green Lady
Green Petal
Harry
Haunted Page
Honeyflutter
Indigowisp
Inferwing
Jader
Kamehameha
Lakeflutter
Limer
Loomer
Lovepuff
Maud
Midnight
Moon Glimmer
Mossback
Murky
Orange Flutter
Orange Petal
Peachbliss
Peeky
Petal Flap
Phlox
Pink Breezer
Pink Glow
Pink Gulf
Pink Handyflap
Pink Kite
Pink Petal
Pink Sliver
Pink Swallow
Pinkleaf
Pinky
Psyclops
Pumkrawler
Purple Flap
Purple Gulf
Purple Handyflap
Purple Morpho
Purple Sliver
Purpy
Red Flutter
Red Lady
Red Morpho
Roseleaf
Rosetide
Rouge Petal
Ruby Wing
Shellycone
Silver Sister
Skin Duster
Skull Snail
Skullglint
Skully
Sluggy
Sourbug
Spiral Snail
Spotted Wings
Spring Wing
Sprouty
Summer Wing
Sunny
Sweetbug
Turdy
Turquoise Sliver
Twigster
Twizzler
Violet Duster
Vitrawing
White Bat
Winter Wing
Yabberwing